Whiskey has been a staple liquor in American culture for centuries, but the rise of flavored whiskeys has put a spin on the classic drink.
One flavor that has gained immense popularity in recent years is peanut butter whiskey.
Our Top Picks For Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Brands
There are many brands to choose from, and it can be tough to decide which ones are worth trying.
In this article, we will take a closer look at the top 12 best peanut butter whiskeys that are sure to please your taste buds.
Discover your new favorite today!
1. Skatterbrain
One of the best things about Skatterbrain is its versatility.
It can be enjoyed straight, on the rocks, or mixed in a variety of cocktails.
The creamy peanut butter flavor adds a unique twist to classic cocktails like Old Fashioneds and Manhattans.
Skatterbrain is made by using the finest ingredients, including the all-natural peanut butter.
The whiskey itself is aged to perfection, giving it a mellow and smooth flavor that pairs perfectly with the rich and creamy peanut butter.
It is not too intense but still has a delicious flavor and aroma that will leave you wanting more.
2. Sheep Dog
When it comes to whiskey, there are countless options available on the market.
Yet, Sheep Dog stands out from the crowd with its distinct and delicious flavor profile.
The peanut butter taste in this whiskey is subtle and well-balanced.
It adds a unique twist to the classic whiskey flavor that is sure to impress even the most discerning whiskey connoisseurs.
The slight hint of saltiness in the whiskey also adds an interesting dimension to the taste, making it a unique experience for your taste buds.
But that's not all - Sheep Dog also has a subtle vanilla flavor that adds to its complexity.
This flavor profile is an excellent and it does not require any extra mixers to enjoy.
The Peanut Butter whiskey from this brand is smooth and well balanced.
3. Skrewball
Skrewball has taken the whiskey world by storm and is quickly becoming a crowd favorite.
It has gained immense popularity in the United States, with whiskey lovers and peanut butter enthusiasts alike raving about its unique flavor.
The whiskey boasts a bold and unmistakable peanut butter flavor that is combined with a smooth and mellow whiskey base.
The taste is not too sweet, but rather balanced with the whiskey's subtle hints of oak and vanilla. The result is a smooth and creamy whiskey that is unlike any other.
The Peanut Butter Whiskey from Skrewball is an excellent base for cocktails.
4. Hard Truth
The Whiskey from Hard Truth is a unique and exciting blend that offers a delightful combination of peanut butter and whiskey.
The whiskey is carefully crafted to create a smooth, sweet taste that is complemented by the rich and intense peanut butter flavor
Its bold and distinctive flavor makes it an excellent choice for those who want to add a little extra kick.
Hard Truth also boasts a light smokiness that adds to its complexity.
This subtle hint of smoke gives the whiskey a depth of flavor that is remarkable.
5. Ole Smoky
The whiskey from Ole Smoky is a delicious and unique blend that is sure to tantalize your taste buds.
The flavor profile is smooth and nutty.
This whiskey is perfect for those who enjoy exploring and experimenting new flavors.
One of the great things about Ole Smoky is its versatility.
The nutty flavor of the whiskey pairs well with a variety of mixers, and can add a unique twist to classic cocktails like the Old Fashioned or Manhattan.
This Whiskey has a subtle sweetness that is balanced by the warmth of the whiskey.
6. Sqrrl
Two appealing aspects of this beverage are the intriguing bottle shape and the amber color.
The Illinois-made whisky from Sqrrl is mildly sweet and guaranteed to go down smoothly.
This whiskey from Sqrrl has a smooth blend of peanut butter and whiskey that has a delicious and creamy taste.
The whiskey has a subtle sweetness that is balanced perfectly by the rich and nutty peanut butter flavor.
The whiskey finishes with a light smokiness, which adds to its complexity.
7. Barrel & Banter
The whiskey from Barrel & Bante has a smooth and flavorful blend of peanut butter.
This whiskey has a slightly sweet taste.
This blend's harmony will appeal to more sophisticated palates.
While still being approachable to those who are unfamiliar with flavored whiskey.
The cinnamon and vanilla notes at the beginning have a sweet flavor.
Yet, Barrel & Banter takes pride in the oaky flavor that their peanut butter whiskey has.
Since it helps in balancing the sweetness for a pleasant sip.
The whiskey has a rich and creamy flavor.
The flavor is balanced with the whiskey's subtle hints of vanilla and honey.
8. Blind Squirrel
This whiskey offered by Blind Squirrel is a straightforward and budget-friendly alternative.
For a seasoned whiskey drinker, the artificial peanut butter flavor and syrupy consistency will feel heavy on the tongue.
But this is a great option, especially for mixers, for a palate that prefers a sweet appeal.
The Flavor profile of Blind Squirrel Peanut Butter Whiskey is bold.
This whiskey has an intense peanut butter taste.
The whiskey has a smooth and sweet flavor that is complemented by the peanut butter's strong and nutty taste.
9. Coastal Creek
The only whiskey on this list that is 60 proof rather than 70 proof is this one.
Coastal Creek is a smooth and delicious blend of peanut butter and whiskey that has an intense peanut butter taste.
The whiskey has a sweet flavor that is complemented by the peanut butter's rich and nutty aroma.
It is also an excellent choice for those who prefer a more intense and robust taste of whiskey.
The Coastal Creek is best served on the rocks or as a dessert pairing.
It is complex yet mild, with a slight burn at the finish to keep you thirsty for more.
10. Two Trees
Two Trees Peanut Butter Whiskey has a rich and creamy peanut butter flavor.
The whiskey has a subtle sweetness that is balanced with the nutty peanut butter taste.
The whiskey finishes with a light smokiness, which adds to its complexity.
Two Trees is perfect for those who enjoy sipping their whiskey straight or mixing in cocktails that require a sweet and nutty flavor.
It is also an excellent choice for those who prefer a smoother and less intense taste of whiskey.
Two Trees Distilling Co. in Fletcher, North Carolina offers nine distinct flavors of flavored whiskey.
11. Bird Dog
Whiskey with a peanut butter flavor? You read that right. Furthermore, it contains the flavor combination you didn't know you needed.
It works because many whiskies and bourbons have flavor and aroma notes of different nuts, so the two are a natural match.
Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey won the 2021 World Whiskies Award for Best American Flavored Whiskey.
12. PB&W
The whiskey from PB&W is a premium whiskey with three different peanut flavor.
These are inspired by their own nostalgia—to create this drink, which has a whiskey-forward flavor profile and the creamiest possible peanut flavor.
It is the ideal fusion of two adored American icons.
Enjoy it straight up or in a delectable combination or cocktail.
FAQs
How should I drink peanut butter whiskey?
These can be enjoyed on their own or mixed in cocktails. They are often served chilled or on the rocks, but can also be mixed with other mixers such as cola or ginger ale.
What is the alcohol content of peanut butter whiskeys?
The alcohol content of these whiskeys varies depending on the brand but is typically around 35-40% alcohol by volume (70-80 proof).
Are peanut butter whiskeys gluten-free?
Most peanut butter whiskey brands are gluten-free, but it is important to check the label or contact the manufacturer to be sure.
Can I use peanut butter whiskey in cooking?
Yes, they can be used in cooking to add flavor to dishes such as sauces, marinades, or desserts.
Wrapping Up!
It may take some time for seasoned whiskey drinkers to warm up to any flavoring, especially one as potentially sweet as peanut butter.
Since this variety of whiskey is one of the most blendable, once you identify your personal favorite, be sure to experiment with different cocktail recipes that add a twist of peanut butter.
Since most whiskeys flavored with peanut butter use artificial flavoring, they are generally safe for people with nut allergies.
Thanks for reading!
